Tourny

[The Smith]

DO you think we should bump some ranks after the tourny and if you do which people deserve it.

[theother]

Well I'm a firm believer in the underdog and think that if you buck the odds several times, you go up. I'm not as big a believer in just because you won five matches, your skill goes up. If you were better than those four of those knights then why should it?

Anyway, here's my suggestions:

Ranger Cracker - for defeating 3 Kingsguard and a fourth knight.
Expert -> Master

Vincent Serry - for defeating two opponents who were equally or more skilled
Noteworthy -> approaching Expert (I think he just falls short based on the joust alone. Perhaps how he does in the Melee could be the decider?)

Marten Lannister - defeating 3 opponents who were equally or more skilled.
Expert -> approaching Master
Slightly contentious being a PC character but I think he's earned it. I was going to say bump him the full way but again, perhaps a good Melee showing could do it?

Ser Vance Hardyng - defeating 3 knights who were equally or more skilled
Noteworthy -> Expert

Jon Royce & Timm Dayne got all the way and Kennos did well but most of their matches were against people with a lesser skill than them or (towards the end) nearing equal. I might see an argument for Kennos approaching Grandmaster but the other two should stay as they are.
Plus I think Jon wearing magic armour is cheating

[theother]

Considering I had both Lord Drumm & Warren Blackwood as Masters, their survival to the end against multiple foes of superior or equal skill was impressive. Possibly bump them to Grandmaster, or approaching Grandmaster?

Once we agree some of these, do we let the NPC "owner" know of their skill secretly/publicly (Horas has asked) or do we keep it to ourselves. Also the Noted/Famed knights thread will probably need updating.
I can't modify your posts by the way. Not sure why.

[The Smith]

Cause I am the main Admin I think. It gives me more power.

I want to bump Keath he had an amazing run, plus Rhodri had trained right up to the threshold of Grandmaster.

I think we should just do it public everyone should know their skills.

Is there any other players that we should bump?

[theother]

No, I think that's it. Timm Dayne is already Legendary.
Rhodri would probably argue for Jon to be made Legendary also but like I said, I don't think beating weaker knights or knights of the same skill should give you experience. The only person he beat who was better than him was Prince Andry and that was in the first round.

[The Smith]

What about Keath. I know his skill don't merit it, but he just about is Legendary. Everyone considers him the best warrior already? Maybe I will just tell Horas that Keath is almost legendary.

[theother]

I thought he was Master and we were bumping him to Grandmaster?
I didn't realise he was already Grandmaster!!
If we bump Kennos, who's a Grandmaster, to Legendary we probably have to bump Jon Royce as well.
We'll have to invent a new title for those above legendary at this rate!!

[The Smith]

No Kennos was master, He just is a legend. I think Grandmaster will be fine, but I will tell Horas that Keath is very close to Legendary.

[theother]

Fair enough.
As I can't amend your posts though, you'll have to do the honours in the Famed/Noted Knights threads

[The Smith]

I am on my way out now though so I will have to do it later.